Up In Your (Family) Business

Sustaining Community Wellness: A Journey with Georgetown Market’s Third-Generation Owner

With Andrew Montieth

Transcript

Summary

This podcast interview is with Andrew Monteith, the third-generation owner of Georgetown Market, a natural health food store located in Indianapolis. The interview covers the 51-year history of the family business, its core values, challenges faced, community engagement, product sourcing, and plans for sustaining its legacy.

 

Key topics discussed include:

  • The origins of Georgetown Market, started by Andrew's grandfather and father in 1973, and its evolution over three generations while staying true to promoting health and wellness.
  • Andrew's personal journey, starting to work at the store from a young age and eventually taking over operations after college.
  • The business's core values of honesty, integrity, building relationships, and providing quality products and excellent customer service.
  • Challenges faced, such as changing demographics, increased competition from corporate health food chains, and maintaining a customer-centric focus amidst technological advancements.
  • Sourcing local and organic products, balancing availability and pricing while upholding quality standards.
  • Community engagement through events, classes, podcasts, and partnerships with local vendors and organizations.
  • Future plans to sustain the business's legacy by staying true to its foundational principles, adapting to industry trends, and continuing to prioritize customer care and education.

 

The interview highlights Georgetown Market's commitment to its values, customer relationships, and promoting health and wellness in the local community over its 51-year history. Andrew emphasizes the importance of maintaining the business's core principles while adapting to changing market conditions and customer needs.

 

Chapters

00:00:16 Introduction and Background

The podcast host introduces Andrew Monteith, the third-generation owner of Georgetown Market, a natural health food store in Indianapolis celebrating its 51st anniversary. Andrew shares how the business was started by his grandfather and father in 1973, initially inspired by a family member's health food store. The store has remained in the same location, with Andrew's grandfather leading it for the first six years before his father took over full-time.

 

00:04:55 Andrew's Personal Journey

Andrew discusses his personal journey with Georgetown Market, starting to work there from a young age and always aspiring to be part of the family business. He shares how he initially studied management at Purdue but later switched to consumer and family sciences, finding it more relevant to the retail industry. After college, he started as the deli manager, gaining hands-on experience before transitioning to other departments and eventually taking on more operational responsibilities.

 

00:23:19 Core Values and Customer Service

Georgetown Market prides itself on its core values of honesty, integrity, building relationships, and providing quality products and excellent customer service. Andrew emphasizes that their focus is on taking care of people and building personal connections with customers, rather than just offering low prices or a sterile shopping experience. He highlights the importance of knowledgeable and passionate employees who genuinely care about helping customers, and how the business's culture and values attract like-minded individuals.

 

00:31:21 Sourcing and Community Engagement

The interview covers how Georgetown Market sources local and organic products, balancing availability, pricing, and quality standards. Andrew discusses the challenges of maintaining organic produce offerings due to pricing constraints but highlights partnerships with local Amish farming communities. The business engages with the local community through events, classes, podcasts, and partnerships with vendors and organizations, aiming to promote health and wellness education.

 

00:40:33 Challenges and Opportunities

Andrew discusses challenges faced by Georgetown Market, such as changing demographics in the area, increased competition from corporate health food chains, and maintaining a customer-centric focus amidst technological advancements. He emphasizes the importance of staying true to the business's foundational principles while adapting to industry trends and customer needs. Opportunities for growth include identifying emerging products and staying ahead of trends, as well as leveraging the personal touch and education that sets Georgetown Market apart.

 

01:07:51 Future Plans and Legacy

Looking to the future, Andrew expresses his commitment to sustaining Georgetown Market's legacy by upholding its core values and prioritizing customer care and education. While open to changes in business models or locations if necessary, he emphasizes that the foundational principles of taking care of people and promoting health and wellness will remain unchanged. Andrew aims to build upon the legacy established by his grandfather and father while putting his own stamp on the business's future direction.

 

Action Items

00:33:05 Continue sourcing local and organic products while balancing availability, pricing, and quality standards

 

00:36:55 Maintain and enhance community engagement through events, classes, podcasts, and partnerships with local vendors and organizations

 

00:49:53 Stay ahead of industry trends and identify emerging products that align with Georgetown Market's values and mission

 

01:10:55 Explore potential changes in business models or locations, if necessary, while upholding the foundational principles of customer care, education, and promoting health and wellness

 

01:08:29 Build upon the legacy established by previous generations while putting Andrew's own stamp on the business's future direction

 

Client Testimonials

arrow_down
“I can’t say enough about how Element212 has come to know our company and how we want to be portrayed, just as if they actually work here. They are very responsive to the needs and constant changes of our growing business, and their team has been a great extension of our company.”
CEO - Modern Trailer Sales
“Element212 has a talented team of hardworking techie people who can explain everything in non-techie language. Most importantly, they get us and they get what we do, they listen to us, and fix our problems quickly.”
Todd Jameson - Renfro Productions
“The team was professional, organized, and very responsive. They took time to understand our business, who we are, and our values. They made our new website exactly what it needed to be. If we had to do it all over again, I would not change a thing.”
Carmen Clift - Beck’s Chimney Sweep
“Element212 was simply fantastic to work with from start to finish. They came highly recommended and lived up to my high expectations. I particularly enjoyed the team approach that they implement and coordinate to ensure complete efficiency throughout the duration of the project.”
Josh Brown - Indy Franchise Law
“Element212 will learn about your business and come up with a strategy that helps you achieve your goals.”
Mark E. - Eagle Creek Nursery
“Element212 has brought along wonderful research and strategy from day one to help us understand the ebb and flow of our brand, as well as the ebb and flow of customer behavior. It’s paid off in dividends.”
Krista Stillwell, Marketing Strategist - Cowpokes Work & Western
“The Brand Insights™ was eye-opening for us. We heard much more about what was actually going on in the mind of the buyer, which helped us dial in our approach, our message, and our go-to market strategy.”
Mark R. - Table XI
“One of the most beneficial takeaways we gained from Element212’s Brand Insights™ process was uncovering why a client did or did not make a purchase with us, along with other valuable data we were unable to capture ourselves.”
Mike Kelly, Managing Partner - DeveloperTown
“We had an excellent experience with Element212! After sitting down at our first meeting, they were able to take what we felt was important with our business and highlight it. To say we were pleased, would be an understatement!”
Andy Arrendale - Quack Daddy Donuts
"Element 212 was exceptional and really helped lead us to a new era in Scope's Digital Footprint. I would most strongly recommend if you are looking to revitalize your online presence, you look no further than Element212!
- Mike Pfarrer, VP of Information Technology - Scope Services Inc.
"Element212 was such a pleasure to work with! Your flexibility, timeliness, and professionalism throughout the recruiting video development have truly made this an experience I will fondly remember. I will recommend you to everyone I know!"
Cynthia Reed - BMM CPAs & Advisors
red_arrow> View Community Partners
red_arrow> View Video Testimonials
Element212 BBB Business Review
Facebook-f Linkedin-in Youtube Instagram
Enews Sign Up:
©2025 Element212

privacy & accessibility

Web Ticket Request
317.296.7314
2701 Enterprise Dr, Suite 107, Anderson, IN 46013
E212-Team
what_we_do
view_our_work
blog
contact
careers